Event details from: C-lab Lecture: Corporate Lawyers’ Ethics in Practice

Date
6 December 2022
Time
16:00 – 17:00

Abstract

Large corporate law firms have experienced accelerated growth and globalisation, and adopted corporate-style management strategies, prompting claims that they have become more focussed on business objectives than professionalism. Existing scholarship explores whether misconduct by corporate lawyers may be influenced by their personal characteristics (‘bad apples’) and/or their firm (a ‘bad barrel’). My empirical work explores whether the market sector in which they practice – the ‘rotten orchard’ – might feature characteristics such as work type, client type, market practices, organisational relationships and/or forces of disruption and continuity which act as situational cues influencing how corporate lawyers act when faced with an ethical dilemma. I have chosen to explore these questions through an empirical study of lawyers practicing in the European private equity and leveraged finance market. Drawing on data from 46 semi-structured interviews with partners and senior associates at leading international law firms, I explore the nuances and complexities of the participants’ everyday experiences. I zoom in on the material practices of their market, the identities they assume and the narratives they deploy to identify the core institutional logics of their practice area. One group of lawyers, the Salesmen, those that act for the arranging banks on the financings of large European cross-border leveraged buyouts (LBOs), tends to adopt a timorous and supine stance in negotiations, selling their opponents’ position to their clients. In contrast, the lawyers facing them in LBO transactions, the Entrepreneurs, who act for major private equity firms, tend to assume an aggressive, exploitative and entrepreneurial identity. The data suggests that both groups of lawyers regularly prioritise pragmatic goals over their own integrity, independence, the interests of their clients, their professional craft and the reputation of the profession. The data raises important questions as to both the influence and observance in corporate legal practice of regulatory codes of conduct and professional and ethical norms.

Bio

Trevor joined the University of Leeds as a Lecturer in Legal Profession in January 2021. Prior to this he was a Teaching Fellow at University College London (UCL), between 2017 and 2020. Trevor was a partner of the international law firm, Linklaters, from 2001 to 2017, in London and Hong Kong, specialising in international finance. Trevor obtained an LLB (1990) and an LLM (2018) from UCL, and in 2018 commenced a PhD at UCL, an empirical study of the ethics and professionalism of corporate lawyers. The focus of his current research is the ethics and professionalism of corporate lawyers. His most recent publication, published in Legal Ethics, is Agency over technocracy: how lawyer archetypes infect regulatory approaches: the FCA example.

Read the publication

Location

REC A3.01

Registration

Send a mail to: t.t.butter@uva.nl